Main menu


Judge Alito mocks foreign critics of abortion reversal.entertainment

featured image

WASHINGTON (AP) — In his first public comment since last month’s ruling, Justice Samuel Alito ridiculed foreign leaders’ criticism of the Supreme Court’s ruling overturning the constitutional right to abortion. garnered more criticism than just some support.

Alito, 72, spoke at a religious freedom summit in Rome and spoke only a few minutes about abortion.

Alito, who wore a tuxedo and sported a beard that sometimes grew when the court was not in session, joked that the judgment he had created was “condemned by a series of foreign leaders” before the British joked that Prime Minister Boris Johnson “paid… the price for his comments”. Johnson called the decision a “huge step back” just before stepping down amid an unrelated ethics inquiry.

About a dozen states have closed or severely restricted abortion within days, following a conservative majority court decision. Ultimately, half of the states in the United States plan to ban or severely limit the procedure.

At a conference sponsored by the University of Notre Dame Law School, Alito also drew laughter from the audience, saying, “It was Britain’s Prince Harry’s remark that really hurt me.” , Harry spoke of “retreating constitutional rights here in the United States” as one of a series of converging crises, including Russia’s invasion of Ukraine.

French President Emmanuel Macron and Canadian Prime Minister Justin Trudeau also caught Alito’s attention when speaking in Rome on July 21 at an invitation-only event. The law school posted a video this week. Alito was not pre-identified as a speaker for the conference.

Mr Johnson’s office did not immediately respond to a request for comment. Prime Minister Trudeau’s spokesman Cecily Roy said: “We will always defend women’s constitutional rights, including the right to choose and receive an abortion. ‘ said.

Judges regularly engage in sharp exchanges in opinion duels with their colleagues, but rarely respond to outside critics. Especially when talking about foreign leaders outside the United States, said Neil Siegel, a law and political science professor at Duke Law School.

“His tone is very negative and scathing. It’s as if he doesn’t care at all that tens of millions of people in this country and abroad are deeply opposed to him.” I think the most important thing is that this is not how our judges behave.”

But Akil Reed Amar, a professor of constitutional law at Yale Law School, said there is no ban on judges from publicly discussing the case after the verdict has been handed down. Alito’s comments were not about the underlying issue of abortion, he said, but about foreign dignitaries complicit in American law, even though they were not necessarily familiar with the issue. For example, Mr Johnson may have tried to divert attention from his own domestic affairs, Amar said.

“This was a little cheeky on their part,” Amar said, also praising Alito for responding “with a little wit and style.”

The attorney general’s speech on Friday drew criticism from United States Representative Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez (DN.Y.).

Professor Michele Goodwin, professor at the University of California, Irvine, and founder of the University of California, Irvine, also cited 17th- and 18th-century English jurists in his opinion that Alito overturned Roe v. Wade. Regardless, he said it was “ironical” to ridicule international opinion. Biotechnology and Global Health Policy Center. “He himself invested in a very esoteric foreign ideology to do what he did with this decision,” he said.

The speech comes at a time when the percentage of Americans who say their faith in the Supreme Court has been eroded is rising sharply. A poll this week by the Associated Press and the NORC Center for Public Affairs found that 43% of Americans said they “very little trust” in the courts, up from just 27% three months ago.

The abortion ruling was one of several significant decisions this summer, but the ruling that overturned Roe v. Wade and ended nearly half a century of guarantees of abortion rights had the widest impact. had an effect.

It has also brought about other major changes in medicine, with some doctors refusing immediate treatment for serious health problems associated with reproductive care for fear of violating strict anti-abortion laws.

Alito’s speech was largely devoted to exalting religious liberty, which conservatives topped in a lawsuit over taxes to religious schools in Maine and the right of football coaches to pray at the 50-yard line. Another area that won the court.

He has served as a judge since 2006 when he was appointed by President George W. Bush.

Four years later, in President Barack Obama’s State of the Union address, Alito responded to Obama’s criticism — also unusual — of another major conservative-led court decision, the Civil Coalition lawsuit, by saying, It was caught on camera uttering the words “not true”. He opened the floodgates to corporate and union spending in the federal election campaign.

Alito has never addressed the controversy publicly, but as evidenced by the questions he posed when the court heard the debate, he said the ruling overturned a century of law. opposed to

Alito never attended the State of the Union address again.


Toronto AP writer Rob Gillies contributed to this report.

Copyright 2022 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed without permission.