Main menu


Controversial Colorado Avalanche Tweet Raises Questions About Objectivity

Longtime sports journalists, like these reporters who covered Mario Lemieux in Pittsburgh in 2001, have been taught to report only the facts, but with the advent of social media, the fandom side of the media has also become a reality. It became clear. (Photo by Rick Stewart/Allsports/Getty Images)

PHOENIX – Is there room for public fandom in the world of sports journalists?

The debate recently took center stage following a tweet by Mike Chambers, the Denver Post’s longtime Colorado Avalanche Beat reporter.

The post shows Chambers holding the Stanley Cup trophy with a cigar in his mouth and a beer bottle visible on the floor next to him. Above the photo, Chambers wrote, “Probably the most memorable experience of my career #StanleyCup.”

Many sports journalists criticized the Avalanche reporters for their lack of objectivity. Many fans didn’t understand the commotion. This suggests that the media was overreacting to a moment of honesty by someone who had become close to someone within the organization.

Longtime sports journalist and New York Times bestselling author Jeff Perlman quoted Chambers’ tweet, writing: ever. ” And sports journalist Leif Skodnick responded: Do what you love. Be part of your team.”

why controversy?

Television cameras and reporters surround Denver Broncos quarterback John Elway before Super Bowl XXI in Costa Mesa, California, 1987. (Photo by Ed Andriski/AP/Shutterstock)

“We’re not fans, we’re not participants. We’re chroniclers,” Perlman told Cronkite News.

The advent of social media has made sports journalism more transparent, providing a forum for not only reporting but also sharing opinions and sometimes fandom.

But the media seems to be doing the math across the board. Pundits have challenged major news networks for blurring the line between objectivity and opinion. In many news programs, the critic and reporter he is merged into one. That’s especially true for political discussions.

“I don’t think it’s a move to opinion. I think it addresses the need to serve the interests of the people,” recently fired CNN reporter Chris Cuomo said last week. said in “Real Time with Bill Maher.” “We were faced with something the media had never seen before in this country. I had to.”

The backbone of journalism has long emphasized neutrality and objectivity, unless defined as a columnist or an expert. A common message in journalism schools is to report only the facts.

According to a Gallup poll released July 18, trust in the news media has fallen to an all-time low, with only 16% of American adults now saying they are “very” or They say they trust them “pretty much”. % on TV news.

Related story

Is that blurry line the reason? Also, could it affect the sports world?

Rick Rodriguez, a longtime journalist and professor at the Walter Cronkite School of Journalism and Mass Communication at Arizona State University, said, “Many people end up in sports journalism because they are fans of sports. It’s often not particularly easy to hide it.” who has taught ethics and investigative reporting classes. Cronkite News is a product of Cronkite School.

“Some of it isn’t hidden in their stories, but I still think that as journalists, they have a duty to seem distant from the team (they’re covering it).”

Chambers, the journalist at the center of the controversy, told Cronkite News in an email that he was asked not to discuss the topic.

The controversy has been gaining momentum over the past decade, with more and more shows appearing on the network: “Two guys in a bar yelling at each other.” Also, the number of voices of fans has increased.

That’s not right, Skodnick said.

“As journalists, we have to hold ourselves to very high standards, which sometimes means blaming[other journalists],” he said.